MSC or Costa: which one should you REALLY choose? The unfiltered comparison

MSC or Costa: which one should you REALLY choose? The unfiltered comparison
MSC or Costa? 🤔 It is the great classic debate among French cruisers, the cruising equivalent of a PSG v OM derby (think Celtic v Rangers). Both lines dominate the French market, both sail from Marseille, both offer similar headline fares… and each has its die-hard fans.

So which one should you really choose? We have compared the ships, the prices (the real ones, with the extras), the food, the atmosphere and the kids' clubs. No bias, and no filter. 🎯

The prices quoted are those published in 2026 by the cruise lines or reported by the trade press. They change often: always check your quote.

🪪 The two lines in brief

🔵 MSC Cruises

  • 🇨🇭 A family-owned line of Italian origin, based in Switzerland, part of the shipping giant MSC
  • 🚢 A fleet of around twenty ships, set to grow to 25 ships in 2027 with the arrival of MSC World Atlantic, built in Saint-Nazaire 🇫🇷
  • 🏗️ A very recent fleet overall, with giants such as MSC World Europa
  • 🏝️ A private island in the Bahamas, Ocean Cay

🟡 Costa Cruises

  • 🇮🇹 A historic Italian line, founded in Genoa, part of the American Carnival group since 1997
  • 🚢 Around eleven ships for the European market
  • 🌱 Two cleaner ships running on LNG (liquefied natural gas): Costa Smeralda and Costa Toscana
  • 🇮🇹 A proudly Italian identity: food, design, atmosphere

💰 Price: the battle of the extras

On paper, Costa is often slightly cheaper on headline fares. But beware: the headline fare means nothing until you have added the extras! 🧮

🏷️ Headline fares (Mediterranean, 7-8 nights, inside cabin)

  • 🟡 Costa: from around €340 per person in low season, around €450-550 in summer
  • 🔵 MSC: around €455 to €725 per person from Marseille

(Prices noted by Ulysse and Le Mag Croisières in 2026, excluding promotions.)

💶 Service charges (compulsory, per night)

  • 🟡 Costa: €11 per person aged 15 and over, and half price from 4 to 14 (€5.50). For departures from 1 December 2026, they rise to €12 and €6. Free for under-4s
  • 🔵 MSC: €12 per person aged 12 and over in Europe (€16 in the Yacht Club), and €6 from 2 to 11. Free for under-2s. The rates changed several times in 2026, depending on the booking date and the cruising region

👉 With young children, the difference is small: around twenty euros over 7 nights for a family of 4, and nothing at all for departures from December 2026. With teenagers aged 12 to 14, however, Costa is noticeably cheaper: MSC charges them the adult rate, Costa half price (a difference of around €90 over a week for two teenagers, still €85 from December). More information in our guide to gratuities.

🍹 Drinks packages (per day per adult)

  • 🟡 Costa "My Drinks": around €23 to €36 when booked online, more expensive on board
  • 🔵 MSC "Easy": around €27 to €47, with drinks up to €7 a glass
  • 🔵 MSC "Premium Extra": around €55 to €75, with drinks up to €14 a glass

⚠️ With both lines, the package is generally compulsory for all adults in the cabin, and a 15% service charge is added to drinks outside the package. Read our analysis: drinks packages, bargain or rip-off?

🏆 Price verdict: Costa has the edge for small budgets and families. But once all the extras are added, the gap narrows considerably, and MSC often runs aggressive promotions. Always compare the total price, not the headline fare!

🚢 The ships

🔵 MSC: the race to go ever bigger

  • ✅ A recent and consistent fleet, with decor often considered more "chic" (marble, Swarovski crystals, shopping galleries)
  • ✅ Impressive new-generation ships (World class, Meraviglia class): indoor promenades with a giant LED screen, waterslides, water parks
  • ❌ Gigantic ships: more than 6,000 passengers on the biggest. See our article on the downside of mega-ships

🟡 Costa: Italy on board

  • ✅ Two recent and spectacular LNG ships (Smeralda and Toscana), decorated as a showcase of Italian design
  • ✅ Older but more human-scale ships on some itineraries
  • ❌ A more mixed fleet: some ships are showing their age
  • ❌ Smeralda and Toscana are giants too (more than 6,000 passengers)

🏆 Ships verdict: MSC has the edge for the modernity of the fleet as a whole. But on Costa Smeralda or Toscana, you won't notice the difference.

🍝 The food

This is THE topic that gets the forums heated 😅. And the opinions are… completely contradictory.

  • 🟡 Costa plays the Italian food card: pasta, pizza, dishes signed by chefs. Many passengers prefer its food in the main restaurant
  • 🔵 MSC is often appreciated for its buffet, more varied and open for longer hours, and for its speciality restaurants (steakhouse, Japanese, Mexican…)
  • ⚖️ With both, quality varies a lot from one ship to another, and even from one cruise to the next

💡 A small practical difference: at MSC, your dinner time depends on your fare. With the basic fare (Bella), it is assigned to you; with Fantastica or Aurea, you can choose it.

🏆 Food verdict: a draw. If you love Italian food, lean towards Costa; if you like variety, MSC. Find out all about dining on board.

🎭 The atmosphere on board

  • 🟡 Costa: a festive and friendly atmosphere, very "Italian-style", with lots of participatory entertainment and themed evenings. Some feel it has lost a little of its Italian soul as it has modernised
  • 🔵 MSC: a little more "chic" in style, with big shows and deck parties. Some travellers find it calmer… depending on the ship and the season

🗣️ And what about French?

Both lines welcome a very international clientele (Italians, Spaniards, Germans, French…). Announcements are made in several languages, and there are always French-speaking staff, but don't expect a 100% French ship. Sailing from Marseille, you will of course meet plenty of fellow French passengers. Our little survival guide to international cruises will help!

🏆 Atmosphere verdict: a matter of taste. Festive and Italian? Costa. More spectacular and a touch more chic? MSC.

👨‍👩‍👧 For families

Both lines are very family-oriented, with free kids' clubs and frequent "kids sail free" promotions (in the parents' cabin, excluding service charges and subject to conditions).

  • 🟡 Costa: 4 free clubs by age group (Mini Club 3-6, Maxi Club 7-11, Teen Club Junior 12-14, Teen Club 15-17), open from 9 am to midnight. Lower service charges for children
  • 🔵 MSC: free clubs from 3 to 17, plus a baby area accessible with parents and a paid babysitting service for babies from 6 months. Recent ships with water parks and attractions

🏆 Family verdict: Costa slightly ahead on budget, MSC slightly ahead for toddlers and attractions. See also our article what to do with your child on a cruise?

👑 The top end

  • 🔵 MSC Yacht Club: a genuine "ship within a ship", with its own suites, restaurant, bar and private pool, a butler, and the Premium Extra drinks package and internet included. It is the benchmark of its kind among mainstream lines
  • 🟡 Costa: suites with perks, but no private area as complete as the Yacht Club

🏆 Premium verdict: MSC clearly ahead. All the details in our comparison of premium options.

⚖️ The summary table

💰 Headline fares: 🟡 Costa
💶 Service charges: 🟡 Costa (especially for children)
🚢 Modern fleet: 🔵 MSC
🌱 LNG ships: a tie (both have them)
🍝 Food: a draw
🎉 Festive atmosphere: 🟡 Costa
✨ Style and big shows: 🔵 MSC
👨‍👩‍👧 Families: a draw
👑 Premium: 🔵 MSC

🎯 So which should you choose?

🟡 Choose COSTA if:

  • 💸 You are on a tight budget
  • 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 You are travelling as a large family (lower service charges for children)
  • 🍝 You adore Italian food
  • 🎉 You like a festive, relaxed atmosphere
  • 🌋 You want to go to the Canary Islands this winter (Costa Smeralda is spending the season there)

🔵 Choose MSC if:

  • 🚢 You want a recent ship, guaranteed
  • 🎭 You love big shows and "theme park" ships
  • 👑 You are aiming for the top end with the Yacht Club
  • 🍣 You like variety with speciality restaurants
  • 🌴 You want to go to the French West Indies this winter (MSC World Europa is deployed there)

💡 The real advice: more than the line, it is often the ship that makes the difference. A brand-new Costa Smeralda will be more modern than an old MSC ship, and vice versa. Compare the ships, the itineraries and the total price, then choose. And to pay as little as possible, read our guide When should you book your cruise?

💬 In short

MSC and Costa are far more alike than people think: same passengers, same ports, same itineraries, same giants of the seas. Costa wins on price and Italian atmosphere, MSC on the modernity of its fleet and the top end.

The good news? Either way, you are going to have a fantastic week at sea. And next time, try the other one and make up your own mind! 😉⛵