Cruise ship crews: between economic opportunity and ethical questions

Cruise ship crews: between economic opportunity and ethical questions

⚓ The reality of working on board: beyond the clichés


When you board a cruise ship, you pass dozens of smiling staff working tirelessly for your comfort. And one question often comes up: is it ethical to enjoy this service when you know about the working conditions? 🤔 Between guilt and economic reality, the situation is far more nuanced than it seems. Let's explore this complex question together, honestly and respectfully.

👷 The reality of working on board: demanding conditions


⏰ An intense pace of work

Let's be honest: working conditions on board are demanding. Here is the reality:
  • Contracts of 6 to 9 months without going home
  • Days of 10 to 14 hours, sometimes more at peak times
  • Working 7 days a week for the whole length of the contract
  • Living in a shared cabin with one or more colleagues
  • No weekends or bank holidays
  • Long periods away from family (6-9 months away from home)

These conditions would send any European or North American running. And it is fair to ask: how can anyone accept that? 😰

💰 Pay that shocks... seen from Europe

Average pay on board (sources: crew accounts and industry studies):
  • Cabin steward/housekeeper: USD 600-1,200/month + tips
  • Restaurant waiter: USD 800-1,500/month + tips
  • Bar staff: USD 900-1,600/month + tips
  • Cleaning and maintenance staff: USD 500-900/month
  • Kitchen staff (commis): USD 800-1,400/month

On top of this come the gratuities, which can represent 30 to 100% of base pay for some roles. But even with gratuities, these amounts look paltry compared with European wages.

For a French person, these figures are shocking:
  • The French minimum wage (SMIC, around €1,400 net) is higher than a steward's pay
  • A steward sometimes earns less than an intern in France
  • For 70 hours of work a week, the hourly rate is ridiculously low

Faced with these figures, unease sets in: am I endorsing a form of exploitation by going on a cruise? 😔

🌍 The economic reality: another perspective


💵 "Low" pay for us, exceptional for them

This is where reality becomes more nuanced. These wages have to be compared with living standards in the crew's home countries:

🇵🇭 Philippines (home to 30% of cruise crews):
  • National average wage: USD 200-350/month
  • Teacher's salary: USD 300-450/month
  • Junior manager's salary: USD 500-700/month
  • A cruise ship steward (USD 1,000 + tips): 3 to 5 times the average wage 💰

🇮🇩 Indonesia:
  • National average wage: USD 150-250/month
  • Graduate engineer's salary: USD 400-600/month
  • A cruise ship waiter (USD 1,200 + tips): 4 to 8 times the average wage

🇮🇳 India:
  • National average wage: USD 150-300/month
  • Teacher's salary: USD 250-400/month
  • A cruise crew member: 3 to 6 times the average wage

Suddenly, the picture changes completely. What looks to us like a pittance is, for many, an extraordinary economic opportunity 🚀

👨‍👩‍👧‍👦 Supporting a whole family

The human reality behind these figures:
  • A Filipino steward earning USD 1,500/month (pay + tips) often supports:
    → His parents
    → His wife and children
    → Sometimes his brothers and sisters
    → In all, 6 to 10 people 👨‍👩‍👧‍👦
  • With this income, he can:
     → Pay for his children's university education
     → Buy a house (impossible on a local wage)
     → Pay for his family's medical care
     → Build up savings for the future
  • In a 6-9 month contract, he earns what would take 3 to 5 years to earn in his home country

This perspective changes everything. It isn't exploitation if it is voluntary and beneficial to both parties... is it? 🤔

⚖️ The ethical dilemma: where do you draw the line?


❌ What would clearly be exploitation

To be clear, here is what would constitute exploitation:
  • Confiscating passports (prohibited by maritime regulations)
  • Debts taken on to get the job (excessive "recruitment fees")
  • Unpaid wages or repeated delays
  • Unlimited working hours (beyond the regulatory 14-16 hours a day)
  • Inhumane living conditions
  • No medical care
  • Not being allowed to resign, or reprisals

Fortunately, modern cruise lines are subject to strict regulations (international maritime conventions, certifications, audits). Abuses still exist, but they are less and less tolerated.

✅ What counts as an economic trade-off

On the other hand, here is the current situation of most employees:
  • Contracts freely signed in full knowledge of the conditions
  • The option not to renew the contract (and many don't after a few years)
  • Wages paid regularly
  • Free board and lodging (a substantial saving)
  • Access to medical care on board
  • The ability to send 80-90% of their pay home to their family (no day-to-day expenses)
  • Valuable professional training (languages, service, hospitality)
  • Opportunities for promotion to better-paid roles

It is a difficult trade-off, admittedly, but it is a trade-off knowingly accepted to improve one's economic situation.

🔄 A question of balance and context


🌐 The trap of economic ethnocentrism

We tend to judge these situations by our European standards. But that is a trap:
  • Imposing "European wages" would make these jobs economically impossible for cruise lines
  • The result? Automation or drastic staff cuts
  • The jobs would disappear, removing this economic opportunity for millions of people

The real issue is not "paying European wages", but:
 → Ensuring decent working conditions
→ Guaranteeing fair pay relative to the local cost of living
→ Respecting workers' fundamental rights

📈 Positive change in the industry

The good news: the industry is making progress:
  • Strengthened international maritime conventions (MLC 2006)
  • Regular audits of working conditions
  • Gradual reduction in working hours
  • Higher base pay (slow but real)
  • Better internet access to keep in touch with family
  • Wellbeing programmes for staff
  • Ongoing training and career prospects

It isn't perfect, but it is getting better. And our vigilance as passengers helps 👀

💡 What can you do as a conscientious cruiser?


✅ Practical, respectful actions

1. Pay the gratuities
  • Never remove the automatic gratuities
  • They make up an essential part of crew income
  • If the service is exceptional, add something extra in cash

2. Treat the staff with respect
  • A sincere smile and thank you are worth a great deal
  • Learn the first name of your cabin steward and your waiters
  • Be patient and understanding
  • Don't be demanding or dismissive

3. Be an "easy" passenger
  • Keep your cabin reasonably tidy (it makes their life easier)
  • Don't waste things (towels, food...)
  • Respect service times

4. Leave a positive review if it's deserved
  • Mentioning staff by name in satisfaction surveys can earn them bonuses or promotions
  • It costs you nothing and means a lot to them

5. Choose responsible cruise lines
  • Find out about social certifications (MLC 2006 compliance)
  • Favour cruise lines that publish reports on working conditions
  • Avoid cruise lines with a known bad reputation

❌ What NOT to do

  • Don't make the staff feel guilty by telling them "you work too hard" (they know, and they made that choice)
  • Don't offer condescending "pity" (it's hurtful)
  • Don't remove the gratuities "on principle" (you punish the wrong people)
  • Don't boycott cruises out of misplaced guilt (it would wipe out these jobs)

🎯 Conclusion: an imperfect but real balance


So, is it ethical to go on a cruise? The answer is nuanced:

❌ No, if you deny the reality:
  • The working conditions are hard
  • The wages look low to us
  • Being away from family is a real sacrifice

✅ Yes, if you understand the context:
  • It is a rare economic opportunity for many
  • These jobs support entire families
  • The wages are far higher than local standards
  • It is a voluntary choice, and a temporary one
  • Conditions are gradually improving

The world is not perfect. The global economy creates imbalances. But between:
  • Offering these imperfect but well-paid jobs
  • Offering nothing at all

The first option is preferable for the millions of people who depend on it.

What matters is to:
  • ✅ Recognise how hard their work is
  • ✅ Respect their dignity and their choice
  • ✅ Contribute fairly through gratuities
  • ✅ Demand that cruise lines improve conditions
  • ✅ Stay alert to abuses

Going on a cruise is not endorsing modern slavery, provided you do it mindfully and respectfully. It means taking part in a system that is imperfect but offers real opportunities to millions of people.

And you, what do you think? Does this nuanced view help you better understand the reality of cruise crews? Share your experience and thoughts in the comments 💬

Note: The pay and conditions mentioned are based on employee accounts and publicly available industry studies. They may vary by cruise line, role and years of experience.